Random Selection On Airline Rebooking Isn't That Random

Image: PHOTO: Airlines Seats. (photo via Flickr/Ronald Sarayudej)
Image: PHOTO: Airlines Seats. (photo via Flickr/Ronald Sarayudej)
Rich Thomaselli
by Rich Thomaselli
Last updated: 11:00 AM ET, Fri April 14, 2017

What is the process for being randomly chosen to be kicked off a flight?

When United Airlines rebooked Dr. David Dao from its Chicago to Louisville flight on Sunday night, eventually leading to a forcible and violent removal from the airplane, the carrier initially said it did so randomly through a computer-generated algorithm.

Except the process isn't really that random, nor is it just a crapshoot with the computer making the selection.

Once certain criteria are factored in the odds might actually have been stacked against Dao.

For starters, airlines routinely overbook their seats. Based on historical data and future projections, airlines realize that about five to 10 percent of passengers will not show up for a flight for reasons ranging from outright cancellation of their reservation to missing their plane.

In this instance, United confirmed that the flight was not overbooked, per se, but it needed four seats for employees who needed to deadhead to Louisville by the morning for flight assignments.

[READMORE]READ MORE: United Paying The Price Over Incident [/READMORE]

United followed the regulations, both federal and internal, and asked for volunteers first. When that didn't work, it went to its random process to select passengers who would be forced to give up their seats (presumably without the violence).

But, the criteria the computer uses narrows the choices, and it starts to create a 'bump list' even before boarding takes place.

Less likely to be chosen - or, for obvious reasons, not chosen at all are:

* Frequent fliers/loyalty program members
* Fliers who bought more expensive tickets
* Passengers who checked in early
* Fliers who have connecting flights (which makes it harder and more expensive for the airline to rebook twice)
* Passengers with disabilities
* And passengers traveling with family, especially unaccompanied minors

So the random choices become much more defined and shrink the pool of available customers. If you don't fall into one of those categories, your chances to be forcibly bumped from on an overbooked flight became that much greater.


For the latest travel news, updates and deals, subscribe to the daily TravelPulse newsletter.

Topics From This Article to Explore

More From TravelPulse

Related Videos

Rich Thomaselli

Rich Thomaselli

Associate Writer

Editor Associate Writer true 9281 14744 Rich Thomaselli has written for TravelPulse since 2014 and has been a professional journalist for nearly 40 years. His work has appeared in USA Today, the New York Times and New York Yankees publications. He is an 11-time writ

Grow Your Travel Business With Certified Courses

Travel Agent Academy
Travel Agent Academy
Majestic Resorts Specialist ProgramDiscover all-inclusive luxury at Majestic Resorts in paradise.
Travel Agent Academy
Travel Agent Academy
Allianz Specialist ProgramProtect every journey with Allianz Partners Travel Insurance.
Travel Agent Academy
Travel Agent Academy
Los Cabos Specialist ProgramSell the magic of Los Cabos: luxury, adventure, and endless sunshine.
Travel Agent Academy
Travel Agent Academy
Majestic Resorts Specialist ProgramDiscover all-inclusive luxury at Majestic Resorts in paradise.
Travel Agent Academy
Travel Agent Academy
Allianz Specialist ProgramProtect every journey with Allianz Partners Travel Insurance.
Travel Agent Academy
Travel Agent Academy
Los Cabos Specialist ProgramSell the magic of Los Cabos: luxury, adventure, and endless sunshine.

Don't Miss These Travel Agent Events and Trainings

Watch Now!
Authentically Mediterranean: Discover Celestyal’s New Western Mediterranean Itineraries & Iconic ClassicsTuesday, July 21, 2026
2:00pm Eastern
The Mediterranean is more than just a destination, it’s our home. Join Celestyal to learn why we are...
Watch Now!
July The Travel Corporation WebinarTuesday, July 21, 2026
2:00pm Eastern
Save your spot for this upcoming webinar! Details coming soon!
Upcoming Webinar
Sani/Ikos Group: Luxury Beachfront Resorts in Greece & SpainTuesday, July 28, 2026
2:00pm Eastern
Join us for an exclusive webinar introducing Sani/Ikos Group, a collection of luxury beachfront...
Watch Now!
Authentically Mediterranean: Discover Celestyal’s New Western Mediterranean Itineraries & Iconic ClassicsTuesday, July 21, 2026
2:00pm Eastern
The Mediterranean is more than just a destination, it’s our home. Join Celestyal to learn why we are...
Watch Now!
July The Travel Corporation WebinarTuesday, July 21, 2026
2:00pm Eastern
Save your spot for this upcoming webinar! Details coming soon!
Upcoming Webinar
Sani/Ikos Group: Luxury Beachfront Resorts in Greece & SpainTuesday, July 28, 2026
2:00pm Eastern
Join us for an exclusive webinar introducing Sani/Ikos Group, a collection of luxury beachfront...