Responsible Travel Raises Questions about Turtle Hatcheries

Turtle hatcheries around the world that claim to be focused on doing good may actually be more interested in cashing in on gullible tourists than helping animals.

And in some cases, the hatcheries may actually be harming turtles.

MORE Tour Operator

New Tour Company Bans Cellphones

Introducing Explorer X

New Malaysian Borneo Tour Provides Close Encounters of...

These are the findings of online travel company Responsible Travel, which recently conducted an investigation into turtle hatcheries around the world.

As a result, the company took the action of removing some trips involving turtle hatcheries from its offerings. In other cases, the company worked with operators to modify trip itineraries.

The bold move represents the first time a travel company has taken such a stand on sea turtle hatcheries.

"The ethics and practices of turtle hatcheries are not widely discussed or written about,” Responsible Travel CEO Justin Francis said. “However, as we delved a little deeper, problems such as overcrowding, the negative impact of handling turtles and eggs, the detrimental effect of keeping hatchlings in tanks and many other issues quickly became apparent.”

The company’s investigation, which included speaking with NGOs, was prompted by a concerned traveler. The process resulted in Responsible Travel developing a new set of guidelines aimed at helping travelers and travel companies identify good and bad offerings.

“Many of our trips include the opportunity to observe nesting or hatching sea turtles, either as part of a holiday or as a volunteer placement. In many cases, well-managed tourism contributes to the conservation of sea turtles, six out of the seven species of which are classified as vulnerable or endangered,” the new Responsible Tourism guidelines state.

The guidelines go on to note, however, that in order for such hatcheries to be successful, strict parameters must be followed, including:

— There must be no interference in the nesting process.

— The numbers of tourists and/or volunteers must be tightly controlled in order to avoid causing distress to the turtles.

The guidelines point out that in some cases, there’s a great deal of human involvement in the nesting and hatching process. The eggs may be removed from nests and placed in hatcheries, either in artificial nests or reburied in protected parts of the beach.

Hatchlings from these efforts may be assisted by volunteers once they emerge or held back for later release. In more extreme cases, the hatchlings are kept in tanks.

Unfortunately, while such hatcheries and tanks have usually been established with the best intentions, they're not always beneficial to the sea turtles, according to Responsible Travel.

"It’s clear that some establishments are 'cashing in' on oblivious tourists who are being led to believe they are helping with turtle conservation during a volunteer project or holiday when in fact, quite the opposite is true,” stated Francis. "Turtle hatcheries should be a last resort; if the threat to the eggs from poaching or erosion is so great they can no longer remain in situ.”

The company is hoping its new guidelines will raise awareness about the importance of both travel companies and travelers themselves asking questions of the places they wish to visit in advance of going there.

Brad Nahill, director, and co-founder of the well-known SEE Turtles, a non-profit that supports conservation efforts and offers volunteer trips that provide opportunities to assist in saving turtles, applauded Responsible Travel's new measures.

Nahill described the new guidelines as well thought out and expressed optimism that, if followed, the guidelines will lead to improved conditions for sea turtle hatcheries that offer tourism as part of their program.

“I absolutely agree with their contention that tanks should not be used to keep hatchlings. There are many places that do this and it can wear the turtle out,” explained Nahill. “I have seen hatcheries where nests are placed too close together. There needs to be space between nests to avoid transmission of disease or infestations between nests, and also to give space for people working in the hatchery to walk in the hatchery without stepping on nests.”

If not done well, handling and moving of eggs can be detrimental and result in lower hatching rates, Nahill additionally said. He also noted that many hatcheries prioritize the tourists’ schedule over the hatchlings, releasing the turtles during the day so that people can take photos, rather than when they should be released, at dusk or at night.

“One way that tourists can check to make sure that the hatchery they visit is a real conservation program is to find out who runs it,” Nahill noted. “If it is a hotel, do they partner with a local conservation organization? Are they part of a network of hatcheries that conduct research and publish their results and findings? They can also contact us and we can try to give advice as well.”

For those who want to see and work with sea turtles on their travels, Responsible Travel continues to support projects that meet its new guidelines. Responsible Travel's full collection of turtle conservation holidays can be found here.