The Pros and Cons of Home Sharing

Image: PHOTO: An Airbnb office. (photo via Flickr/Open grid Scheduler)
Image: PHOTO: An Airbnb office. (photo via Flickr/Open grid Scheduler)
Patrick Clarke
by Patrick Clarke
Last updated: 3:45 PM ET, Wed May 3, 2017

While a majority of Americans haven't and won't consider booking through Airbnb or other home-sharing sites, more than nine out of 10 U.S. adults who have booked a homestay say they are likely to do it again, according to a recent survey from Consumer Reports.

The independent, not-for-profit consumer organization's National Survey Research Center surveyed more than 2,000 Americans as part of its "Homes Away From Home: The Appeal-and Pitfalls-of Home-Sharing" report and found that 92 percent of U.S. travelers that have booked a home-sharing service are likely or very likely to become a return guest.

More than half of respondents (53 percent) indicated their experience was "very good" while more than one-third (37 percent) said their experience was at least "good."

The survey also uncovered that saving money is the biggest reason travelers turn to homestays like Airbnb and HomeAway, with 70 percent citing that motivation in particular. Citing a report from Morgan Stanley, Consumer Reports points out that an Airbnb rental in the U.S. can cost as much as 17 percent less than an upper-scale chain hotel.

Unique accommodations (58 percent) and kitchen availability (53 percent) are among the top reasons Americans opt for home-sharing sites. Culture is also a major draw. According to the survey, 75 percent of Americans who have never tried a homestay but would consider it said they would give it a shot just to dive into the local culture.

Still, there are some fears that keep many Americans glued to traditional hotels.

Although two out of three survey respondents (65 percent) reported no problems with their homestay experience, half of Americans wouldn't even consider booking straight from the owner, with a majority refusing because they don't know what to expect.

Safety concerns (55 percent) and not wanting to interact with homeowners (40 percent) are two other notable factors, according to the report.

[READMORE] READ MORE: Airbnb vs. Hotel: Which is Right For You? [/READMORE]

"While home sharing services may offer consumers a chance to save money on a unique experience, services and consumer protections vary," said Lauren Lyons Cole, CFP and Consumer Reports money expert, in a statement. "Travelers should be aware of what they are getting into before opting for a vacation rental."

Since there are potential pitfalls in booking a homestay, Consumer Reports highlights advice for travelers.

This includes diving deep into the review section, carefully comparing prices and attempting to negotiate a discount whenever possible.


For the latest travel news, updates and deals, subscribe to the daily TravelPulse newsletter.

Topics From This Article to Explore

More From TravelPulse

Related Videos

Patrick Clarke

Patrick Clarke

Senior Editor

A Maryland native and wanderer who has lived across the U.S. from North Carolina to SoCal, Patrick Clarke graduated from Towson University with a B.S. in journalism. He previously worked for Bleacher

Grow Your Travel Business With Certified Courses

Travel Agent Academy
Travel Agent Academy
Los Cabos Specialist ProgramSell the magic of Los Cabos: luxury, adventure, and endless sunshine.
Travel Agent Academy
Travel Agent Academy
Majestic Resorts Specialist ProgramDiscover all-inclusive luxury at Majestic Resorts in paradise.
Travel Agent Academy
Travel Agent Academy
Allianz Specialist ProgramProtect every journey with Allianz Partners Travel Insurance.
Travel Agent Academy
Travel Agent Academy
Los Cabos Specialist ProgramSell the magic of Los Cabos: luxury, adventure, and endless sunshine.
Travel Agent Academy
Travel Agent Academy
Majestic Resorts Specialist ProgramDiscover all-inclusive luxury at Majestic Resorts in paradise.
Travel Agent Academy
Travel Agent Academy
Allianz Specialist ProgramProtect every journey with Allianz Partners Travel Insurance.

Don't Miss These Travel Agent Events and Trainings

Upcoming Webinar
MSC Cruises: A Year in Motion — Learn More, $ell MoreMonday, September 21, 2026
2:00pm Eastern
MSC Cruises just wrapped its first-ever Alaska season, and it's only the beginning. Join Erin Douglas...
Upcoming Webinar
Destination Weddings & HoneymoonsTuesday, September 22, 2026
2:00pm Eastern
Join Travel Weekly TravelAge West, and TravelPulse as we showcase romantic hotels and resorts designed...
Upcoming Webinar
The Islands of the Bahamas: 16 Islands, Endless LuxuryWednesday, September 23, 2026
2:00pm Eastern
The modern luxury traveler demands far more than breathtaking aesthetics, they seek effortless...
Upcoming Webinar
MSC Cruises: A Year in Motion — Learn More, $ell MoreMonday, September 21, 2026
2:00pm Eastern
MSC Cruises just wrapped its first-ever Alaska season, and it's only the beginning. Join Erin Douglas...
Upcoming Webinar
Destination Weddings & HoneymoonsTuesday, September 22, 2026
2:00pm Eastern
Join Travel Weekly TravelAge West, and TravelPulse as we showcase romantic hotels and resorts designed...
Upcoming Webinar
The Islands of the Bahamas: 16 Islands, Endless LuxuryWednesday, September 23, 2026
2:00pm Eastern
The modern luxury traveler demands far more than breathtaking aesthetics, they seek effortless...