Train Versus Plane: When It Makes Sense to Skip the Plane Ride to Cut Carbon Emissions

Image: PHOTO: Amtrak's Pacific Surfliner train. (photo via Flickr/Doug Letterman)
Image: PHOTO: Amtrak's Pacific Surfliner train. (photo via Flickr/Doug Letterman)
Mia Taylor
by Mia Taylor
Last updated: 8:00 PM ET, Tue September 24, 2019

As travelers around the world increasingly heed the call to be proactive in the face of climate change, it brings about the question of how best to reach destinations in an eco-friendly and time-effective manner while seeking to cut back on carbon emissions.

It's a quandary that hasn't gone unnoticed by the travel experts at Hipmunk, who recently took a deep dive into their data to identify routes around the country where it might make the most sense to swap your plane ride for a train.

"The most comfortable, convenient, and cost-effective alternative to a plane ride is taking the train. In fact, if you take a train, you cut carbon dioxide (CO2) by half compared to a plane ride covering the same distance," said Hipmunk in releasing the data.

While travel via rail may indeed be greener and even cheaper than travel by air, that doesn't mean the length of a train trip will always work best for your schedule or make the most sense.

With those competing concerns in mind, Hipmunk has broken down the data to identify the options for travelers hoping to be more eco-conscious and cut back on carbon emissions associated with flying.

Here's a sampling of the routes identified by Hipmunk as offering the largest savings (based on median round trip booking prices) for train routes when compared to flight routes, along with the in-trip time difference you will be tacking on (hours, one-way) when opting to travel by train:

St. Louise to Chicago

-Median train price: $55

-Median flight price: $309

-Extra trip duration: 4.3 hours

Seattle to Vancouver

-Median train price: $54

-Median flight price: $257

-Extra trip duration: 2.6 hours

Pittsburgh to Philadelphia

-Median train price: $97

-Median flight price: $458

-Extra trip duration: 6.0

Vancouver to Seattle

-Median train price: $72

-Median flight price: $278

-Extra trip duration: 3 hours

Tampa to Ft. Lauderdale

-Median train price: $59

-Median flight price: $173

-Extra trip duration: 3.7

San Diego to Los Angeles

-Median train price: $46

-Median flight price: $129

-Extra trip duration: 1.8

Portland to Seattle

-Median train price: $56

-Median flight price: $153

-Extra trip duration: 2.6 hours

Detroit to Chicago

-Median train price: $96

-Median flight price: $204

-Extra trip duration: 3.6 hours

The full table of Hipmunk data on train versus plane options can be found here.

Hipmunk's data comes at a time when travelers are increasingly looking for alternatives to flying. Led by the efforts of high-profile figures like Greta Thunberg and filmmaker-naturalist David Attenborough, a growing number of flyers have become pollution conscious and are acting on their concerns.

One last parting note about those looking for greener options when booking travel. Hipmunk has long been a leader when it comes to offering travelers more environmentally friendly alternatives for transportation.

Since 2011, the site has been showing users Amtrak train trips alongside flight results on routes where Amtrak provides service.

The site provides train schedules and prices where available in both Hipmunk and Concur Hipmuk search results and also shows such details as to whether the train offers Wi-Fi, which we all know is critical to travelers in this day and age.

As you book your travel, look for sites that offer a variety of transportation alternatives.


For the latest travel news, updates and deals, subscribe to the daily TravelPulse newsletter.

Topics From This Article to Explore

More From TravelPulse

Related Videos

Mia Taylor

Mia Taylor

Senior Editor

Mia Taylor is an award-winning journalist who has two decades of experience. Most recently she worked as a staff writer for America's largest digital publisher DotdashMeredith, where she contributed stories on a daily basis to four of the company's most iconic brands - Parents,Real Simple, Better Homes & Gardens, and Health. Her work has also appeared in Travel + Leisure, The Boston Globe, The San Diego UnionTribune, Westways Magazine, Fortune, and more.

Grow Your Travel Business With Certified Courses

Travel Agent Academy
Travel Agent Academy
Puerto Vallarta Specialist ProgramEnveloped in the beauty of a by-gone time, this colorful town on Mexico’s Pacific Coast is sure to win...
Travel Agent Academy
Travel Agent Academy
Korea Travel Specialist ProgramThis course will allow you to explore this fascinating country's incredible diversity of experiences...
Travel Agent Academy
Travel Agent Academy
Costa Rica Specialist ProgramCosta Rica Specialist Program academy ENROLL NOW Costa Rica offers golden shores, fish-filled waters,...
Travel Agent Academy
Travel Agent Academy
Puerto Vallarta Specialist ProgramEnveloped in the beauty of a by-gone time, this colorful town on Mexico’s Pacific Coast is sure to win...
Travel Agent Academy
Travel Agent Academy
Korea Travel Specialist ProgramThis course will allow you to explore this fascinating country's incredible diversity of experiences...
Travel Agent Academy
Travel Agent Academy
Costa Rica Specialist ProgramCosta Rica Specialist Program academy ENROLL NOW Costa Rica offers golden shores, fish-filled waters,...

Don't Miss These Travel Agent Events and Trainings

Upcoming Webinar
Worry-Free Access to the World - Part 1Monday, July 13, 2026
2:00pm Eastern
Join Travel Weekly, TravelAge West, and TravelPulse for Worry-Free Access to the World, a webinar...
Upcoming Webinar
July Avanti Destinations WebinarTuesday, July 14, 2026
2:00pm Eastern
Save your spot for this upcoming webinar! Details coming soon!
Upcoming Webinar
Sell More, Your Way: Real-World Avanti Success Stories with Two Top AdvisorsTuesday, July 14, 2026
2:00pm Eastern
Join Avanti Destinations’ Director of National Accounts, Ken Pringle, and two high-performing travel...
Upcoming Webinar
Worry-Free Access to the World - Part 1Monday, July 13, 2026
2:00pm Eastern
Join Travel Weekly, TravelAge West, and TravelPulse for Worry-Free Access to the World, a webinar...
Upcoming Webinar
July Avanti Destinations WebinarTuesday, July 14, 2026
2:00pm Eastern
Save your spot for this upcoming webinar! Details coming soon!
Upcoming Webinar
Sell More, Your Way: Real-World Avanti Success Stories with Two Top AdvisorsTuesday, July 14, 2026
2:00pm Eastern
Join Avanti Destinations’ Director of National Accounts, Ken Pringle, and two high-performing travel...