Airbnb vs. Hotels: New Data Shows Travelers' Preferences

Image: PHOTO: Family enjoying a homestay. (photo via monkeybusinessimages/iStock/Getty Images Plus)
Image: PHOTO: Family enjoying a homestay. (photo via monkeybusinessimages/iStock/Getty Images Plus)
Alex Temblador
by Alex Temblador
Last updated: 7:00 PM ET, Tue May 14, 2019

Hotels have been struggling over the years to keep the attention and loyalty of travelers since Airbnb has hit the scene.

Clever Real Estate conducted a survey of 1,000 Americans to see what travelers prefer, and they found that most travelers are "Team Airbnb."

According to the survey, 60 percent of leisure travelers who use both hotels and Airbnb prefer the home rental platform versus hotels. However, 68 percent of business travelers prefer hotels and have negative experiences using Airbnb for work.

In terms of reviews, Airbnb experiences are only slightly more positive with an average of 4.3 stars for home rental properties versus 4.2 stars for hotels. So while travelers are satisfied with both Airbnb and hotels on a similar level, many seem to choose Airbnb for the price, access to home amenities and the local, authentic experience they provide.

Perhaps surprising then is that 53 percent said that they have privacy concerns with vacation rentals, with 58 percent concerned primarily about hidden cameras. Seven percent of those surveyed had found a hidden camera in their unit, and yet only 12 percent believe Airbnb rentals are uncomfortable and 10 percent see them as unsafe.

Despite hidden camera fears, most travelers still have a positive outlook on Airbnb. Seventy-one percent see it as a positive route in terms of global tourism.

Airbnb isn't just gaining in popularity for travelers but for homeowners as well. Fifty-four percent of homeowners said they would consider renting out their homes as 82 percent believe it's a good way to make money from their property.

Still, there is hope for hotels. Marriott's Home & Villas luxury rental service is becoming more widely-known among travelers. Half of all luxury travelers have heard of this new service and like that it is integrated into Marriott's reward program.

Topics From This Article to Explore

Get To Know Us Better

Agent At Home

Helping leisure selling travel agents successfully manage their at-home business.

Subscribe For Free

Agent Specialization: Group Travel

Laurence Pinckney

Laurence Pinckney

CEO of Zenbiz Travel, LLC

About Me
Agent At Home

Helping leisure selling travel agents successfully manage their at-home business.

Subscribe For Free

Agent Specialization: Group Travel

Laurence Pinckney

Laurence Pinckney

CEO of Zenbiz Travel, LLC

About Me

Become A Travel Expert

Upcoming Webinar
Zoëtry Wellness & Spa Resorts WebinarSEP 26 2PM ETLean how an intimate getaway at Zoëtry artfully balances unrivaled luxury and personal well-being.
Upcoming Webinar
Porter Airlines WebinarSEP 28 2PM ETJoin Porter's webinar and learn how we are turning the idea of economy air travel "upside down".
Upcoming Event
Destination Leisure Travel ExpoOctober 11-12 2-5PM ETDestination Leisure Travel Expo
Upcoming Webinar
Zoëtry Wellness & Spa Resorts WebinarSEP 26 2PM ETLean how an intimate getaway at Zoëtry artfully balances unrivaled luxury and personal well-being.
Upcoming Webinar
Porter Airlines WebinarSEP 28 2PM ETJoin Porter's webinar and learn how we are turning the idea of economy air travel "upside down".
Upcoming Event
Destination Leisure Travel ExpoOctober 11-12 2-5PM ETDestination Leisure Travel Expo