Fewer Choices for NYC–Toronto Travelers as American Airlines Pulls Out

Image: American Airlines plane in flight. (Photo Credit: American Airlines)
Image: American Airlines plane in flight. (Photo Credit: American Airlines)
Laurie Baratti
by Laurie Baratti
Last updated: 2:55 PM ET, Sun December 14, 2025

American Airlines is trimming its flight schedule again—and this time, a busy cross-border route is on the chopping block.

Starting in May 2026, the carrier will discontinue its nonstop service between New York’s John F. Kennedy International Airport (JFK) and Toronto Pearson International Airport, ending a route it will have operated for more than three years. The move means fewer nonstop options for travelers flying between two of North America’s biggest cities.

The change was first reported by Aviation A2Z, which noted that “American Airlines (AA) is ending its New York JFK to Toronto service as cross-border demand between the U.S. and Canada remains soft.” American had been flying up to two daily roundtrip direct flights on the route since launching it in January 2023.

While American hasn’t publicly detailed the reasoning behind the decision, Aviation A2Z speculated that “American appears to be reallocating capacity toward higher-performing domestic and international routes,” which aligns with airlines' usual strategy of prioritizing profitability when deciding how to deploy their resources. 

There’s also evidence that demand for U.S.-Canada travel has cooled in recent months. In its coverage, The Street cited BBC reports indicating that many Canadians have been avoiding travel to the U.S. amid ongoing political tensions. The outlet referenced data from Canada’s statistics office showing that “Air travel from Canada to the U.S. dropped nearly 24 percent” in October, while “Car travel fell more than 30 percent when compared to the same period last year.” 

American’s decision could inconvenience plenty of travelers—especially those who already had trips planned later this year. Passengers who had planned on taking affected flights will need to adjust their itineraries, perhaps by switching to a competing airline. Fortunately, Air Canada and Delta Air Lines will continue to offer multiple daily flights between the two cities, supported by strong hub connections on both ends. 

Projections for early 2026 suggest the market will average nearly seven daily flights, with about 517 seats in January and 512 seats in April, while American is still in the mix.


For the latest travel news, updates and deals, subscribe to the daily TravelPulse newsletter.

Topics From This Article to Explore

More From TravelPulse

Laurie Baratti

Laurie Baratti

Assistant Editor

Laurie Baratti is an Assistant Editor for TravelPulse. She is a San Diego-based journalist whose work has previously appeared in publications like TravelAge West, SPACE, Modern Home + Living, Montage, and Sandals Life magazines. Travel writing has long been her passion, and she is always looking for excuses to explore the world outside of her native California. Laurie is also a lifelong equestrian, a proud pet-parent, and an underground advocate of the Oxford comma.

Grow Your Travel Business With Certified Courses

Travel Agent Academy
Travel Agent Academy
Los Cabos Specialist ProgramSell the magic of Los Cabos: luxury, adventure, and endless sunshine.
Travel Agent Academy
Travel Agent Academy
Allianz Specialist ProgramProtect every journey with Allianz Partners Travel Insurance.
Travel Agent Academy
Travel Agent Academy
Majestic Resorts Specialist ProgramDiscover all-inclusive luxury at Majestic Resorts in paradise.
Travel Agent Academy
Travel Agent Academy
Los Cabos Specialist ProgramSell the magic of Los Cabos: luxury, adventure, and endless sunshine.
Travel Agent Academy
Travel Agent Academy
Allianz Specialist ProgramProtect every journey with Allianz Partners Travel Insurance.
Travel Agent Academy
Travel Agent Academy
Majestic Resorts Specialist ProgramDiscover all-inclusive luxury at Majestic Resorts in paradise.

Don't Miss These Travel Agent Events and Trainings

Upcoming Event
Selling More with TAP: Unlock the Value of Portugal StopoverMonday, November 9, 2026, 2:00PM EasternJoin TAP Air Portugal and Visit Portugal for an exclusive webinar dedicated to TAP's Portugal Stopover...
Upcoming Webinar
Wildlife, Culture & Warm-Weather AdventureTuesday, November 10, 2026, 2:00pm EasternFrom extraordinary wildlife encounters to vibrant cultures and breathtaking landscapes, discover how...
Upcoming Webinar
Black Friday Is Just the Beginning with ALG Vacations®Wednesday, November 11, 2026 2:00pm EasternJoin ALG Vacations® on November 11 for a special webinar featuring Jacki Marks, Jim Tedesco, and Ben...
Upcoming Event
Selling More with TAP: Unlock the Value of Portugal StopoverMonday, November 9, 2026, 2:00PM EasternJoin TAP Air Portugal and Visit Portugal for an exclusive webinar dedicated to TAP's Portugal Stopover...
Upcoming Webinar
Wildlife, Culture & Warm-Weather AdventureTuesday, November 10, 2026, 2:00pm EasternFrom extraordinary wildlife encounters to vibrant cultures and breathtaking landscapes, discover how...
Upcoming Webinar
Black Friday Is Just the Beginning with ALG Vacations®Wednesday, November 11, 2026 2:00pm EasternJoin ALG Vacations® on November 11 for a special webinar featuring Jacki Marks, Jim Tedesco, and Ben...